Measuring the ROI of Your Company's Matching Gift Program

Measuring the ROI of Your Company’s Matching Gift Program

/in /by

Corporate matching gift programs are one of the most effective ways for companies to amplify their charitable impact. These programs match employees’ donations to nonprofit organizations, effectively doubling or even tripling the contributions. However, as with any other business initiative, companies need to measure the ROI (or return on investment) of their matching gift program to assess its effectiveness and ensure they are getting the most out of their resources.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll walk you through measuring the ROI of your corporate matching gift program, from setting the right goals to tracking key metrics. By the end of this article, you’ll have a clear understanding of how to evaluate the success of your program and identify opportunities for growth. We’ll cover:

Before diving into the specifics of measuring ROI, it’s important to first understand the foundational elements that make a corporate matching gift program successful. In the sections that follow, we’ll explore key aspects of ROI measurement, from basic definitions to actionable insights, and provide you with a roadmap for optimizing your program’s performance.

Let’s begin.

What is ROI in a Matching Gift Program?

Before diving into the specifics of measuring ROI (or return on investment), it’s essential to understand what it means in the context of a corporate matching gift program. At its core, return on investment is a metric that measures the financial return on an investment relative to its cost. In the case of matching gift programs, ROI refers to the financial benefits (i.e., the amount of matched donations) versus the investment a company makes to administer and promote the program.

When measuring ROI for matching gifts, companies need to assess:

  • The total amount of matching gift contributions successfully requested by employees
  • The administrative costs related to running the program
  • The indirect benefits, like employee engagement, retention, and positive brand perception

Calculating ROI helps companies determine whether the investment in the matching gift program is worth it and whether adjustments are needed to improve its performance overall.

Why Measuring Matching Gift Program ROI is Important

Measuring (and generating) ROI for your matching gift program is crucial for several reasons. First, it helps determine the success and impact of your program, ensuring that the resources allocated are being used effectively. Second, understanding your program’s ROI allows you to make informed decisions about future investments, optimize program operations, and adjust your strategies when necessary.

Here are a few key reasons why measuring ROI is essential for matching gift programs:

1. Justifying the Program’s Continuation

Without proper ROI analysis, companies may struggle to justify continuing or expanding their matching gift program. By demonstrating a positive ROI, however, you can present a compelling case for sustaining or enhancing the initiative.

2. Optimizing Resource Allocation

Effective measurement helps identify areas where resources (e.g., time, effort, and money) are being underutilized or misallocated. By understanding ROI, companies can allocate funds and effort to the program areas that deliver the highest returns, whether that’s outreach, administration, or employee engagement.

3. Enhancing Employee Engagement

A solid ROI analysis doesn’t just look at the financial side of the program; it also helps assess employee satisfaction and engagement. The more engaged employees are in the matching gift program, the greater the likelihood of increased participation and higher overall donation amounts.

4. Improving Future Philanthropic Initiatives

Lastly, knowing how to measure the success of a matching gift program helps companies better plan future CSR initiatives. If you find that certain aspects of the program aren’t performing as expected, it provides a chance to fine-tune these elements and improve outcomes in future campaigns.

Key Metrics for Measuring Matching Gift Program ROI

Measuring the ROI of a matching gift program requires tracking various key metrics that give insight into how well the program is performing. While your selected KPIs may vary, below are the most important metrics you should be monitoring:

1. Total Matched Donations

The most straightforward metric for calculating ROI is the total amount of money that a company matches in donations. This is the program’s most direct financial return; for the best results, track both the overall matched contributions and individual employee matching gift submissions.

2. Employee Participation Rate

The number of employees participating in the matching gift program plays a significant role in measuring ROI. A higher participation rate often indicates greater employee engagement and satisfaction, which leads to more donations and, ultimately, a higher return.

3. Matching Gift Submission Rate

Not every employee who donates will submit a matching gift request. Therefore, measuring the submission rate (the percentage of eligible donations that are matched) is crucial. A higher submission rate suggests that employees are actively using the program, thereby resulting in an improved ROI.

4. Administrative Costs

You also need to measure the cost of administering the matching gift program. These costs include staff time, marketing and outreach efforts, and any software or tools you use to manage the program. By keeping these costs under control, you can improve your overall ROI.

5. Employee Retention and Satisfaction

While not directly tied to financial outcomes, employee retention and satisfaction rates can be important indicators of matching gift program ROI. A successful matching gift initiative fosters a positive corporate culture, which may lead to lower turnover and higher employee morale. These long-term benefits can contribute to higher ROI in human capital.

6. Return on Investment (ROI)

The final metric you’ll want to track is ROI itself. The formula for calculating ROI in a matching gift program is relatively simple:

ROI = {Total Matched Donations − Administrative Costs}/Administrative Costs

This formula calculates the net return on investment by comparing the matched donations with the program’s operating costs. The higher the number, the greater the ROI you’ve achieved.

Calculating Matching Gift Program ROI: Steps and Formula

To accurately measure the ROI of your matching gift program, it’s essential to follow a systematic approach. Here’s a step-by-step breakdown of the process:

Step 1: Collect Data

Start by gathering data on the total amount of employee donations and the matching funds provided by the company. Don’t forget to track the administrative costs associated with managing the program, including staffing, outreach, and software.

Step 2: Calculate Matched Donations

Calculate the total amount of money that was donated by employees and matched by the company. This will form the bulk of your ROI calculation.

Step 3: Subtract Administrative Costs

Take the total administrative costs for running the program (including marketing, software tools, and staff salaries) and subtract them from the matched donation figure. This gives you the net contribution from the matching gift program.

Step 4: Apply the ROI Formula

Now that you have all the necessary numbers, apply the ROI formula mentioned earlier. This will give you a percentage that represents the return on investment.

Tools and Technologies to Track ROI

There are various dedicated platforms available to help track the ROI of a company’s matching gift program. These solutions can streamline data collection, automate calculations, and provide valuable insights into program performance.

Here are a few main types of tools to consider:

1. Matching Gift Platforms

Software platforms like YourCause, Benevity, and CyberGrants (as well as CLMA-certified solutions like Millie, Selflessly, and Uncommon Giving) can simplify program management, helping companies efficiently monitor the success of their corporate giving initiatives and calculate ROI with greater accuracy.

2. Employee Engagement Surveys

To measure employee engagement and satisfaction, consider using surveys or feedback tools (such as Google Forms) to gauge how employees feel about the matching gift program. From there, tracking employee sentiment can help you understand the program’s impact on retention and overall morale.

3. CRM and Donation Tracking Systems

CRM systems and donation tracking software can help your company keep a close eye on donation data, program costs, and employee interactions with the program. These systems are invaluable for both tracking ROI and ensuring that data is accurate and up to date.

Strategies for Improving Matching Gift Program ROI

Once you’ve measured the ROI of your corporate matching gift initiative, it’s time to optimize and improve on your efforts. Here are a few strategies to increase your return on program investment:

1. Enhance Employee Awareness

A common reason for low participation rates is that employees are simply unaware of the matching gift program or don’t understand how it works. Improving communication through regular internal emails, webinars, and workshops can increase awareness and boost engagement.

2. Streamline the Submission Process

Making it easier for employees to submit matching gift requests can improve participation and, by extension, ROI. Ensure that the submission process is simple and intuitive, with clear instructions and a user-friendly platform to power your company giving.

3. Offer Incentives for Participation

Some companies incentivize matching gift submissions by offering recognition or rewards to employees who participate. This could take the form of public acknowledgment, small prizes, or even charity giving stipends.

4. Promote Program During Peak Giving Seasons

Take advantage of peak giving seasons (like the end of the year) to promote the matching gift program. Creating campaigns around these times can lead to a spike in participation and donations.

Wrapping Up & Next Steps

Measuring the ROI of your corporate matching gift program is essential to understanding the effectiveness of your philanthropic efforts. By tracking key metrics, calculating ROI, and using the right tools, you can ensure your program operates optimally and delivers significant value to both employees and the company. Good luck!

Drive matching gifts with the right software